Sixteen court cases have all decided converting railroads in to trails is an unconstitutional taking of land. When the easements were granted, land owners never granted an easement to make a trail. Each court case pointed out a trail is not a railroad. That means in order to make a trail, the land owners must receive fair market value for the new easement. Expect millions of dollars to be added to the cost of trails.
Filed under: Marin, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad, Sonoma
The move could make it easier for the rail authority to defend the cargo trains, which returned to Sonoma, Napa and Marin counties in July after a 10-year absence.
Filed under: Marin, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad, Sonoma
NCRA releases environmental report on freight service | PressDemocrat.com.
The North Coast Rail Authority on Wednesday took another step toward resurrecting freight service in Napa, Sonoma, Marin and Mendocino counties by releasing a final environmental impact report.
Filed under: Humboldt, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad
But some Eel River ranchers are skeptical of the idea, saying they already have problems with poachers, marijuana growers and other trespassers.
“We will fight you on this,” said Peggy Satterlee, whose family owns a 28,000-acre ranch in the canyon near Fort Seward.
“We don’t want the dogs, the horses and the fires,” she said.
Filed under: Humboldt, Marin, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad, Sonoma
A MARCH 24 Marin Voice column, “Lopsided freight train lease,” [and other papers] by North Coast Railroad Authority board member Bernie Meyers is a “lopsided” opinion. Meyers does not speak for the board.
We invite the public to view his insinuations and compare them with the facts about the NCRA process and operator contract as detailed below.
The NCRA entered into a lease agreement with North Western Pacific Co. in 2006. A board member may disagree with the terms of that operator agreement, but it is wrong to suggest that the process took place behind closed doors.
The NCRA used a request-for-proposals process, which was widely publicized, and the selection of the operator was accomplished at a public meeting in May 2006.
That selection was subject to negotiation of a contract, which came back before the board in an open meeting in September 2006.
The “fairness” of the contract has to be viewed at the time of its making, not through the lens of subsequent events.
At the time the contract was signed:
• The railroad had been closed down for eight years.
• The California Transportation Commission had stated it would not allocate any Transportation Congestion Relief Program funds to the NCRA.
• The NCRA had a pending $10 million claim from its previous Operator, which had to be resolved before any third party, such as NWP, could operate.
• The Union Pacific had said they would never do business with the NWP (the former operator) railroad again.
• NCRA did not even have enough resources to pay its staff.
This was the situation when the agreement was signed. Most of the other short-line railroads solicited did not even respond. Rail America stated that it was not interested under any circumstances.
Against this challenging and pessimistic backdrop, NWP agreed to:
• Assume the common carrier obligation.
• Support NCRA staff at the rate of $20,000 per month, without knowing whether the railroad would ever reopen.
• Risk up to $4 million cash of its capital to fund the TCRP project, with little security in the event of project failure, and knowing that Caltrans might disallow some or all of the costs.
In addition, when contractors who were hired to get the railroad open failed, NWP risked an additional $2 million to get the job done.
NWP has brought credibility to this railroad through its commitment, competence and capital.
NWP and John Williams have risked much to bring an operating railroad to the public, a facility that has great value to present and future generations of citizens and businesses.
Nobody else offered to take the risks that Williams did and without those risks being taken, NCRA meetings would be nothing more than dream sessions, wishfully looking forward to the day when rail service might be restored.
The only price NWP asked in return for taking 100 percent of the risk was to be reimbursed for the cost of money spent for the NCRA.
We hear a lot these days about public/private partnerships and the NCRA board is blessed with some tenacious directors.
Bernie is one of them.
But to give credit where credit is due, the NCRA had little hope of success without the unswerving faith and full credit of its private partner, NWP and John Williams.
Former Mendocino County Supervisor Hal Wagenet is chariman of the North Coast Railroad Authority, which plans to run freight trains on tracks that cross Novato.
Filed under: Humboldt, marijuana, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad, Southern Humboldt, trails, Willits
Madrone estimates the trail would cost between $300 million and $400 million to build
That is a quote from the trail adviser, unlike Sims who used any person from the audience.
A railroad easement is there until the railroad is abandoned. It doesn’t matter if the line has been inactive for twenty-five years or more.
The railroad is not required to use creosoted wood. Other alternatives are concrete, steel, plastic, rubber, and other wood resistant to rot.
We rail advocates understand it will be a long hard path.
With ever increasing fuel costs, there is a rising need for the railroad. The railroad can haul one ton of freight for an average of 426 miles on one gallon of fuel. A truck on the other hand hauls one ton of freight for about an average of 118 miles on one gallon of fuel. With rising tensions and population around the world, do we really want to be stuck with a less efficient transportation?
Security is of paramount importance, so ERTA promotes use of technology here. A “trail card” system with solar-powdered automated trail stations could be located at all of the approx. 15 main ERT access points from paved roads. The cards could have a proximity sensor function, so that if someone gets lost, we would know which section they last passed through. It is much easier to search 5 or10 miles than it is 162 miles. All trail users could be required to provide next of kin contacts and planned date of arrival at a given access point. There could be different types of trail cards, like single or multiple day-use as well as annual or lifetime passes, for locals or frequent users.
How many people do they really think is going to pay for trail use? Enough for $400 million in costs, not to mention maintenance costs? Does he really think anyone will use this security card, let alone MJ Growers? I’m sure DEA will not subpena the records.
BTW, NCRA said the rails, etc is theirs, and will be used for the rest of the system if this is railbanked. So if you are counting on $400 million from scrapping the relatively small amount, forget it. Also the scrap won’t even add up to what they need.
Filed under: Humboldt, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad
New group gathers thousands of signatures to convert unused railroad to trail
Happy Trails podcast said they gathered 5k sig with both counties.
Filed under: Mendocino
Water diversion suit rejected by state – Ukiah Daily Journal.
A bummer, I was hoping they would win on this one.
Filed under: bicycle, Humboldt, Marin, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad, Samoa, THA, trails, Ukiah
THA Gaining Gorgeous Train Cars – April 28, 2010 [with photos]
Cal Park Hill Tunnel project gets final dollars, to open in October
The Cal Park Hill Tunnel is expected to open to the public in October after a regional agency this week approved almost $3 million for final work on the project.
Inmates clean up around the railroad tracks
Inmate crews have been organized by Ukiah to clean up the overgrown corridor of the railroad tracks this week.
Crews out of the Chamberlain Creek Conservation Camp west of Willits got started on the project Monday near the renovated rail depot on Perkins Street. The crews had leveled overgrown grass and bushes from Perkins south to about the Grace Hudson Park.
Filed under: Arcata, bicycle, Blue Lake, Eureka, Humboldt, Manila, Marin, Mendocino, NCRA, Northwestern Pacific Railroad, Railroad, Samoa, SMART, Sonoma, THA, trails
NORTH COAST RAILROAD AUTHORITY (NCRA)
REGULAR BOARD MEETING
Wednesday, March 10, 2010~ 10:30 a.m.
Humboldt County Board of Supervisors Chambers
825 5th Street, Eureka
Humboldt County
DRAFT AGENDA
AGENDA NOTE
All items appearing on the agenda are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to action by the Board of
Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to change by the Board.
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. ROLL CALL
C. AGENDA APPROVAL
D. PUBLIC COMMENT
Comments will be limited to three minutes per person and not more than ten minutes per subject, so that everyone can
be heard. “Public comment” time is limited to matters under the jurisdiction of the Authority that may not have been
considered by the Authority previously and are not on the agenda. No action will be taken. Members of the public may
also comment during specific agenda items when recognized by the Chair.
E. PRESENTATIONS
1. Spencer Clifton – Annie & Mary Trail Update
2. Karen Diemer – Arcata to Bracut Trail Update
3. Gerry Tomczak – Timber Heritage Association Update
F. DISCUSSION ITEMS (no action required)
1. Status of Lombard-Windsor Repair Project – Lifting of Emergency Order 21
2. Status of RRIF Loan
3. Status of November 5, 2009 Russian River Division EIR
4. SMART/NCRA Revised Operating Agreement
2
5. Sale of the Ukiah Depot
6. NCRA/SMART Joint Use of $8.6 mil. in ISTEA Funds
7. April 7/8 CTC Meeting
8. Novato Consent Decree
G. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Approval of Minutes – Regular Board Meeting – February 13, 2010
2. Acceptance of Minutes – Finance Committee Meeting – January 10, 2010
3. Acceptance of Minutes – Finance Committee Meeting – February 10, 2010
4. Acceptance of Sonoma County Financial Statements – February 2010
5. Acceptance of NCRA Financial Statements – February 2010
6. Approval of Warrants Issued – Agency 787010 – February 2010
7. Approval of Cal Card Statement – February 2010
H. OPERATOR REPORT
1. NWP Co. – John Williams
I. LEGAL COUNSEL REPORT
1. C.J.Neary
J. MATTERS FROM THE BOARD
K. CLOSED SESSION
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUSEL – ANTICIPATED LITIGATION
Significant exposure to litigation pursuant to Govt. Code Section 54956.9(c) one case
2. CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS
Govt. Code Section 54956.8
Property – Ukiah Depot Property
Negotiating Parties – Caltrans, City of Ukiah, County of Mendocino, Weston
Solutions, Union Pacific Railroad
Under Negotiation – regulatory matters, existing and potential contractual matters,
price, payment, terms
Agency Negotiators – C.J. Neary, Mitch Stogner
L. ANNOUNCEMENT OUT OF CLOSED SESSION
M. ANNOUCNEMENT OF NEXT MEETING
April 14, 2010 – 10:30 a.m.
Corte Madera Best Western – Terrace Suite
56 Madera Blvd.
Corte Madera
Marin County
Looks like there is a little bit for everybody.
